IT’S BURGER TIME!!! Remember this game?
The burger craze of NYC has revved up to fucking high gear by now. It’s a full-on onslaught offensive, the likes of which has not been seen since the German Blitzkrieg.
You may want to prime your eyeballs with this amazing video too.
Then there’s this masterpiece… If this doesn’t get you into a burger mood then you are not human:
THE SOUP DUMPLING BURGER
On the other hand, if you are like many other burger aficionados, you may be a purist. Ground beef, cheese, buns. Avoid complications.
I may be a bit late to the burger party, but below is a collection of places I’ve dined at for burgers.
Keep in mind when reading these reviews that I tend to favor a potato bun, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo. I almost always go for jalapenos, especially if they are fresh (not pickled), and I will sometimes get bacon. Also, I hate burgers that stack up too high and become unruly to eat. Last, I cut my burgers in half. I hate when I get food on my face, and cutting the burger makes me feel like I am having a neater meal for some weird reason. For a little bit more on what needs to be done to craft the best burger, check out my post called “The Secrets to Crafting a Great Burger.”
Here are my top five restaurant burgers, in no particular order. Note that they are each a bit different in style from the classic American, which I tend to love most:
Here are my top five fast casual burgers, also in no particular order. These are all classic American style burgers:
- Belcampo Meat Co
- Lucky’s Famous
- Ethy’s Alcohol & Food
- Hard Times Sundaes
- Porter House (bar burger double)
Here’s another top five for you: steakhouse burgers.
- Peter Luger
- Tuscany Steakhouse
- Antique Bar & Bakery (rib eye burger for four)
- Red Hook Tavern
- Bowery Meat Co
Below is a full alphabetical listing of all the burgers I chowed down on throughout the area:
- 1 2 3 Burger Shot Beer
- 4 Charles Prime Rib
- 5 Boro Burger
- 5 Napkin Burger
- 7th Street Burger
- 20 Grams Cafe
- 21 Club
- 77 West (Bahamas)
- 82 Stanton
- Ada’s Place
- Ai Fiori
- The Ainsworth (Chelsea)
- Alfie’s
- All American
- American Cut
- The Anthony (CLOSED)
- Antique Bar & Bakery
- Ardyn
- Atto Prime
- Au Cheval Diner
- Balthazar
- Bar Boulud
- Bar Sardine
- Bareburger
- The Baroness
- Bastard Burger
- Beach Bunnies (Ft. Lauderdale)
- Beautique (CLOSED)
- The Bedford
- Bedford & Co.
- Beetlehouse
- Belcampo
- Ben & Jack’s (44th Street)
- Benjamin Steakhouse (White Plains)
- Best Burger NYC
- Big Daddy’s
- Big Nick’s
- Bill’s Bar & Burger
- Billy Goat Tavern
- Bistro Pierre Lapin (CLOSED)
- Black Crescent
- The Black Derby
- Black Emperor
- Black Iron Burger
- Black Tap (SoHo) (Burger Crawl)
- Blue Collar
- Blue Ribbon Federal Grill
- Bluebird London NYC
- Bo Caphe
- Boilermaker
- Bonnie’s Grill
- Boucherie (Burger Crawl)
- Bowery Meat Company
- Boylan Heights
- The Breslin
- BRGR
- Brickyard Gastropub
- The Brindle Room
- Bronson’s Burgers
- Bully’s Burgers (Hawaii)
- The Burgary
- Burger & Barrel
- Burger & Lobster
- Burger Bistro
- Burger Fi
- Burger Heaven
- The Burger Joint
- Burger King’s Halloween Whopper
- Burger Queens
- Burgers on B
- Burgers & Cupcakes (CLOSED)
- Burger Shack (Bahamas)
- Burke & Wills
- BV’s Grill (CLOSED)
- Cafe O’Lei (Hawaii)
- Caliente Cab
- The Cannibal (CLOSED)
- Cantiere Hambirreria
- The Capital Grill
- Carla
- Causwell’s (SF)
- Cecchi’s
- Centurion
- Charlie Palmer Steak
- Charly’s (CLOSED)
- Chat n Chew
- Cheeseburger in Paradise (Hawaii)
- Chimichurri Grill
- Chumley’s
- Church Street Tavern
- Circo
- Clarke’s Standard (CLOSED)
- Cliff’s Rendezvous
- The Clocktower
- Clover Grill (New Orleans)
- Cochon Butcher (New Orleans)
- The Commodore II
- Concrete
- The Consulate
- Corner Bistro
- Coterie (New Orleans)
- Covina
- Cow Pig Bun (Hawaii)
- Crazy Burger
- Dag’s Patio Cafe
- DB Bistro Moderne
- Death Avenue
- Delmonico’s
- Del Frisco’s Grille
- Denny’s
- Dolly Varden
- Donohue’s
- Dudley’s
- E’s Bar
- Ear Inn
- Eastwood
- Ed’s Chowder House (CLOSED)
- Eel Bar
- The Elgin
- Em
- Emilia by Nai
- Empire Burger House
- Empire Diner
- Empire Steakhouse East
- Ethyl’s Alcohol & Food
- The Fat Monk (CLOSED)
- Five Guys Burger & Fries
- Flame
- Flo’s Luncheonette
- Fuku+
- Gallagher’s
- Gebhard’s Beer Culture
- Gemma
- Genuine Roadside (CLOSED)
- Gotham Burger Social Club
- Grazin’ Diner (Hudson, NY)
- Great Jones Distilling
- The Grill
- Gupshup
- Hall’s Chophouse
- Hamburger America
- Hancock Street
- Handcraft Kitchen & Cocktails
- Handcraft Burgers & Brew
- The Happiest Hour
- Hard Times Sundaes
- Harlem Shake
- Harold’s Meat + Three
- Harry’s
- Haswell Green’s
- Hawksmoor
- Heartland Brewery
- Holy Cow
- Holy Ground
- Hooters (CLOSED)
- House of Brews
- Houseman
- Hudson Eatery
- Hudson Yards Grill
- Hudson & Charles Dinette
- In n Out (SF)
- International Wings Factory
- Intersect by Lexus
- The Irish Pub
- Iron Bar
- Island Burger
- Jack & Charlie’s
- Jack’s Sliders & Sushi
- Jackson Hole
- Jasper’s Taphouse & Kitchen
- Jax BBQ
- Jeffrey’s Grocery
- Jeremy’s Ale House
- J.G. Melon
- Jimbo’s
- Joe’s Bar (CLOSED)
- Joe Jr.
- Joe’s Sirloin Burger
- Johnny Rocket’s
- Jones Wood Foundry
- Jonny Panini
- Joy Burger Bar
- Judge Roy Bean Public House
- King’s Cafe
- Kings of Kobe (CLOSED)
- Kingside
- L & L Drive Inn (Hawaii)
- La Frite
- La Pecora Bianca
- The Lambs Club
- Landmarc (CLOSED)
- Le Burger
- Le Cirque (CLOSED)
- Le Monde
- Le Rivage
- Legasea Bar & Grill
- Les Enfants de Boheme
- Liberty Prime Steakhouse
- The Lions Bar
- Little Frog
- Little Jack’s Tavern (Charleston)
- Little Rebel
- Louie’s Backyard (Key West)
- Lovely’s Old Fashioned
- Lucky’s Famous Burgers
- M. Wells
- Maialino
- The Malt House (West Village)
- The Malt House (FiDi)
- Manhatta
- Manhattan Proper
- Massoni
- Maysville
- McHales
- Mel’s Burger Bar
- Melt Shop
- Mighties
- Mikey’s
- Mila’s Fish & Hook
- Milk Burger
- Minetta Tavern
- Mischa
- Mister Paradise
- Montmartre (CLOSED)
- Mother Burger
- Ms Yoo
- Mt Kisco Diner
- The National
- Nelly Spillane’s
- Nevada Smith’s
- New York Burger Co.
- Nicky’s on the Bay
- The Norm
- North River Lobster Company
- Nusr-Et
- NYY Steak (CLOSED)
- Old Town
- Osteria Morini
- Pao de Queijo
- Parlor Steakhouse (CLOSED)
- Pastis
- Paul’s Da Burger Joint
- The Penrose
- Peter Luger Steakhouse (Brooklyn)
- Pete’s Tavern
- Petey’s Burger
- Pier A Harbor House
- Pig Beach
- Pig Bleecker (CLOSED)
- Pincecrest Diner (SF)
- Pineapple Club
- P.J. Carney’s
- P.J. Clarke’s
- The Playboy Club (CLOSED)
- Pomodoro Rosso
- Pomona
- Porter House (Burger Crawl)
- Queensyard
- Rainbow Room
- Raoul’s
- Red Hook Tavern
- Redeye Grill
- Resto (CLOSED)
- Ristorante Morini (CLOSED)
- Rosie O’Grady’s Saloon
- Rothman’s (CLOSED)
- Route 66 Cafe
- Ruby’s
- Saigon Social
- Salty Dog
- Salvation Burger
- San Diego Burger Co. (San Diego)
- San Matteo Pizza
- The Saratoga (SF)
- Schilling
- Schnipper’s Quality Kitchen
- Shake Shack
- The Shakespeare
- Shari’s Cafe & Pies (CA)
- Smashburger
- Smashed
- The Smith
- Smokey Burger
- Spiegel
- The Spotted Pig (CLOSED)
- Stagecoach Tavern
- Steak Frites Bistro
- Steak n’ Shake (CLOSED)
- Stecchino (CLOSED)
- Suprema Provisions
- Swagyu (San Diego)
- TAK Room
- Tanner Smith’s
- Taproom No.307
- Ted’s Montana Grill
- Teddy’s Bigger Burger (Hawaii)
- Thalia (CLOSED)
- T.J. Finley’s
- T.J.’s Hero Shop
- Tuscany Steakhouse
- Umami Burger
- Vaucluse
- The Villager
- The Vine
- Wagyu Social
- Wahlburger’s (CLOSED)
- Warren 77
- The Wayland
- West Side Steakhouse
- The Whiskey (Orlando)
- White Castle
- The White Spot
- Whitman’s (at City Kitchen)
- Wicked Willy’s
- Wm Farmer & Sons (Hudson, NY)
- YAKS on the 5 (CA)
- Zeppelin Hall
- & Son